Published in Blog

Modern slavery in Ireland

Written by  Monday, 30 January 2017 17:59 Be the first to comment!
Dr. Esohe Aghatise, founder, and director of Associazione Iroko Onlus in Italy, discusses job options with a victim of sex trafficking. Dr. Esohe Aghatise, founder, and director of Associazione Iroko Onlus in Italy, discusses job options with a victim of sex trafficking. Credit: Kay Chernush for the U.S. State Department.

 


There is an old engineering proverb that it is easier to fix the problem than it is to fix the solution. Its wisdom is this: avoid flawed presumptions that lead to false solutions. One Irish newspaper covered a recent publication by the U.S. State Department on human trafficking globally. 78 suspected victims of human trafficking, or modern-day slavery, were located in Ireland in 2015 the newspaper disclosed: 22 were mere children, and 48 were exploited in the sex trade. In response, an editorial momentarily struck the right note by pointing to market behaviour, before proceeding to conjure the dependable bogeyman of the Catholic Church, and using the Church to springboard spectacularly to a position from where it advocated it was “time to legalise and regulate this industry – and better protect those who are forced to work in it”. Can the sex trade be regulated? Is it in the interests of the trade to be regulated? Fortunately the days when these questions were purely speculative have passed.

One of the objections to prostitution is that it commodifies human beings. This objection asserts that prostitution treats fellow human beings as items of trade, or as mere commodities. This objection is itself the source of a counter-objection, because it is a moral argument, and moral arguments are not en vogue nowadays. It is true, this is indeed a moral argument, but this is only part of the picture, as it is also an economic one. Exceptions aside, the economics of prostitution are the very same economics belonging to commodities. They assure that it is never in the interests of the trader to be burdened with costs, even those of a regulatory regime. This is why regulation does not belong to the sphere of prostitution, because it is incompatible with the economics interests of prostitution, and it is too why proponents of regulation are attempting, not to fix the problem, but to apply a solution which simply does not fit.

In 2000 the Dutch legalised prostitution with the expectation of regulation. To impose the necessary control they set about trying to establish what needed to be regulated. To do this Dutch law required prostitutes to register. Advocates of legalisation appear to have taken the trade’s consent to comply for granted, but from even the earliest days of the new regime it was not forthcoming. Thirteen years later, it was much the same with a petition from the Prostitution Information Center, opposing basic measures because, it claimed, “Government databases are never temporary and never secret. Anyone registered as prostitute in the database will carry that label for the rest of their life. Although the Netherlands is a so-called ‘tolerant’ society, the limits to Dutch ‘tolerance’ and social acceptance are narrower than one might think,” it added. These measures deemed absolutely critical, by the country’s national rapporteur on trafficking, to producing some semblance of meaningful regulation had to be abandoned and even stripped from law before it could be passed. The Dutch may have intended to regulate prostitution, but success does not rest on intent.

Establishing even the most basic of facts about the trade there today remains difficult. Nobody can say, for example, precisely how many prostitutes operate in the Netherlands, even after all these years. The shroud which once enveloped the trade remains in place, but where it was once used as a reason to legalise it, it is now used to defend the trade against criticism now that it has been legalised. All that can be relied upon comes in the form of estimates. Terrifyingly, one of these, given in this year’s edition of the Global Slavery Index, puts the population of modern-day slaves in the Netherlands at a staggering 17,500 persons. Yes, that’s 17,500 slaves! Given that sex trafficking in prostitution is the main form of human trafficking experienced in the Western World, the sex trade in the Netherlands must predictably account for most of those held in slavery there. Is this the solution we seek to emulate?

With over 45 million believed to be living in its grasp, slavery has returned to the world. Ireland can certainly choose to legalise prostitution. It will not succeed at regulating it however, for the very same reasons the Dutch have failed. One can promote the cause of prostitutes or the cause of prostitution, but one cannot promote the cause of both. It has always been so, for it was written of King Cotton at the South, that he was not slowed by “the cries of the oppressed, while the citizens of the world are dragging forward his chariot, and shouting aloud his praise!” This is the choice before Ireland today: do we consent to protect the consumer or the consumed.

Read 1681 times Last modified on Wednesday, 01 February 2017 17:21

Got something to say? Go for it!

Make sure you enter all the required information, indicated by an asterisk (*). HTML code is not allowed.


 
 

Open Secrets: An Irish Perspective on Trafficking and Witchcraft

Open Secrets: An Irish Perspective on Trafficking and Witchcraft explores modern slavery, human trafficking, and their slaves, all from the perspective of present-day events in Ireland.

Happening Now

Sauk Rapids Church to Host Human Trafficking Prevention Training

SAUK RAPIDS – A pair of local churches will host a community training focused on human sex trafficking in the United States and how people...

Manager among 3 arrested for human trafficking at Colorado Springs Travelodge

According to police, 48-year-old Stephanie Milan was the manager of Travelodge, and she faces charges of human trafficking for sexual servitude and ...

Justice Department drops drug trafficking charges against former Mexican defense minister ...

Cienfuegos was indicted by a federal grand jury in New York in 2019 and accused of conspiring to participate in an international drug distribution and ...

Three arrested in bust on suspected people smuggling ring

Authorities in Greece arrested three suspected members of a people-smuggling gang responsible for transporting migrants from Greece to Italy, the ...

Protecting Migrant Workers from Deceptive Recruiting Tactics

Traffickers often target specific populations who are most vulnerable to trafficking, such as people in poverty or refugees, both of which may take any ...

Are our laws cut out for addressing systemic exploitation?

As many people will already be aware, the prevention of and fight against human trafficking has also been closely linked with the struggle against ...

Police in Florida's capital announce 178 arrests in child sex trafficking probe

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — A large-scale human trafficking investigation conducted over two years in north Florida resulted in 178 arrests, police said ...

Anti-trafficking is an inside job

The Financial Sector Commission on Modern Slavery and Human Trafficking, hosted by the Dutch foreign minister, Stef Blok, meets in The Netherlands ...

Did a Teen Sell His Kidney in Exchange for an iPhone?

Illegal organ trafficking in China had dire consequences for this teenager's technological aspirations. Nur Ibrahim. Published 17 November 2020.

Thistle Farms and End Slavery TN team up for their first safe house in Middle...

Globally, human trafficking and prostitution are a huge money-making industry. "It is the fastest-growing crime globally," said Margie Quin, CEO of End ...

Colorado Launches Campaign To Fight Human Trafficking

(CBS4)- Colorado is launching a new awareness campaign highlighting the dangers of human trafficking. The goal is to expose the crime and help the ...

'Operation Stolen Innocence': 170-plus people charged in Florida child sex trafficking network

Some 106 people were charged with felonies, including human trafficking, lewd and lascivious battery on a child under 16 and production and ...

Brexit talks creating 'tremendous uncertainty' in NI, says Bill Clinton

Human trafficking. Separately, a senior PSNI officer has warned that organised crime gangs could exploit the Border for human trafficking after the end of ...

Colorado Human Trafficking Council launches awareness campaign

DENVER (KDVR) — After three years in the making and a grant from the federal government, the Colorado Human Trafficking Council (CHTC) has ...

COVID Crisis: India's Children Risk Greater Exploitation

In addition to providing education, schools in India also ensure children's safety by protecting them from traffickers and forced marriages. Additionally, ...

178 people in Tallahassee area arrested in 'large-scale' child trafficking investigation

The department recently concluded a two-year-long operation, called "Operation Stolen Innocence," involving human trafficking and child sex trafficking ...

Stolen goods Georgians buy online funds human trafficking and drugs, investigation finds

Channel 2′s Tom Regan learned Georgia is in the top ten of a multibillion-dollar criminal enterprise, that often has links to drug and human trafficking ...

Police arrest four people in connection with hotel human trafficking, prostitution ring

Stephanie Milan, 48, Ronald Rutherford, 52, and Edward Wayne Monroe, 40, face human trafficking and pimping charges stemming from a police ...

Dozens of sick and hungry Central American migrants, including three minors, are rescued from ...

The 44 migrants from El Salvador and Guatemala were held in two rooms and only fed once a day by the human smugglers, who promised...

Third Committee Approves 11 Drafts, among Them 4 Covering Women's Rights, Omnibus Text on ...

Also approved today were draft resolutions on: trafficking in women and girls; child, early and forced marriage; the human rights treaty body system; ...

Three held for kidnapping, trafficking infant to childless couple in Telangana

Police suspect the trio could be a part of a bigger human trafficking syndicate and further investigation is underway. According to police, the infant was ...

Local advocacy groups pleased with recent human trafficking arrests

D'IBERVILLE, Miss. (WLOX) - This week, the state attorney general's office and the Mississippi Bureau of Investigations arrested six people as part of ...

35-year-old sentenced to 7-months imprisonment for human trafficking in Osun

Represented by Mrs Caroline Zaruwa, the National Agency for Prohibition of Trafficking in Persons, NAPTIP, told the court that the convict and some ...

FinCEN Issues Human Trafficking Advisory (Part II of II)

Human traffickers, like all criminals, rely on the international financial system to facilitate their crimes and to disguise proceeds from their illegal activities.

Tema Regional Immigration Command foils a human trafficking deal

The Tema Regional Command of the Ghana Immigration Service (GIS) has busted a Nigerian woman at the centre of a trafficking deal which purports ...

Dog The Bounty Hunter's daughter Lyssa launches mission to find missing children and sex ...

They were all in sex trafficking, all labeled as runaways. “We feel very passionately about this - we didn't choose this. This is choosing us....

Romania's sex trafficking trade: 'There is no other life they know'

The baby is due in a matter of weeks. "Bianca" is 13 years old. She was forced to have sex with men every day or...

BRIEFS: CBI recognizes Grand Junction agencies

The state of Colorado has scheduled a remote news conference at 10 a.m. today to increase awareness about the many forms of human trafficking ...

Eight Indonesian migrant workers rescued from illegal captivity in Malaysia

Authorities have charged the agency's boss, a female resident of Miri city, with human trafficking. On Nov. 5, the Indonesian Consulate General in ...

More Indonesian sailors repatriated from deadly Chinese fishing fleet

Officials from three Indonesian recruitment agencies have been charged with human trafficking in connection with the case. JAKARTA — Eighty-eight ...

Site offers protection for domestic violence victims

“Survivors of human trafficking should never have to live with the fear that their perpetrator may one day identify where they reside,” Mike Hein, Office...

Bishops face the challenge of 'healing the world,' Archbishop Pierre says

... of the largest clouds is the 'throwaway culture,' which leads to disregard for human life — in the forms of abortion and euthanasia, human...

WATCH: Human trafficking a growing problem

“If the women say they were held against their will that's kidnapping and it's a criminal offence.” The Women's Directorate in the Office of the...

The man who sold a kidney to buy an iPhone 4 can't get out of...

Later, nine people involved in the operation were arrested and since then five have been charged with intentional injury and organ trafficking.

Human trafficking is focus of online film festival

Each day will feature a different theme relevant to human trafficking. The festival gets underway Tuesday, Nov. 17, with Opening Night. The rest of the ...

Texarkana groups promote awareness of human trafficking

Lauren Booker started the group Texarkana Against Trafficking to bring awareness to human trafficking and give the community resources to help stop it.

Exploitation is the rule, not the exception

Workers have no choice but to sell their labour in order to live and, when they ... described as freely offered: it is “not voluntary,...

You can help stop human trafficking by playing a game

News 10 – WTHI-TV | myFOX10 | CW 10 | ION 800 Ohio Street Terre Haute, IN 47807 USA Main Phone: 812-232-9481. Newsroom: 812-232-4953

Mother, children jailed 34 years for human trafficking, exploitation

Adeyinka Adedipe, Benin. A Benin High Court, Edo State, on Monday sentenced a woman and her children to 38 years' imprisonment for trafficking a ...

New statewide human trafficking hotline launches today

Respond, rescue, restore, and revive - that is the mission of The LifeGuard Group as they work with victims of human trafficking and launch an...

About David Lohan

David Lohan is an author and researcher on modern slavery, a phenomenon otherwise known as human trafficking. He first encountered the issue of modern slavery during his work with an organization providing outreach to refugees and asylum seekers. His first book on the subject, a co-authored work, explored the role played by African witchcraft in present-day slavery. He holds a bachelor's degree in engineering and several post-graduate qualifications. His Master of Art (Politics) research explored policy approaches aimed at combating slavery. He is presently working on his second book on modern slavery.

With a commitment to victims of modern slavery.

© Copyright 2016 by DavidLohan.com. All Rights Reserved.

Back to the top.