Published in Blog

Modern slavery in Ireland

Written by  Monday, 30 January 2017 17:59 Be the first to comment!
Dr. Esohe Aghatise, founder, and director of Associazione Iroko Onlus in Italy, discusses job options with a victim of sex trafficking. Dr. Esohe Aghatise, founder, and director of Associazione Iroko Onlus in Italy, discusses job options with a victim of sex trafficking. Credit: Kay Chernush for the U.S. State Department.

 


There is an old engineering proverb that it is easier to fix the problem than it is to fix the solution. Its wisdom is this: avoid flawed presumptions that lead to false solutions. One Irish newspaper covered a recent publication by the U.S. State Department on human trafficking globally. 78 suspected victims of human trafficking, or modern-day slavery, were located in Ireland in 2015 the newspaper disclosed: 22 were mere children, and 48 were exploited in the sex trade. In response, an editorial momentarily struck the right note by pointing to market behaviour, before proceeding to conjure the dependable bogeyman of the Catholic Church, and using the Church to springboard spectacularly to a position from where it advocated it was “time to legalise and regulate this industry – and better protect those who are forced to work in it”. Can the sex trade be regulated? Is it in the interests of the trade to be regulated? Fortunately the days when these questions were purely speculative have passed.

One of the objections to prostitution is that it commodifies human beings. This objection asserts that prostitution treats fellow human beings as items of trade, or as mere commodities. This objection is itself the source of a counter-objection, because it is a moral argument, and moral arguments are not en vogue nowadays. It is true, this is indeed a moral argument, but this is only part of the picture, as it is also an economic one. Exceptions aside, the economics of prostitution are the very same economics belonging to commodities. They assure that it is never in the interests of the trader to be burdened with costs, even those of a regulatory regime. This is why regulation does not belong to the sphere of prostitution, because it is incompatible with the economics interests of prostitution, and it is too why proponents of regulation are attempting, not to fix the problem, but to apply a solution which simply does not fit.

In 2000 the Dutch legalised prostitution with the expectation of regulation. To impose the necessary control they set about trying to establish what needed to be regulated. To do this Dutch law required prostitutes to register. Advocates of legalisation appear to have taken the trade’s consent to comply for granted, but from even the earliest days of the new regime it was not forthcoming. Thirteen years later, it was much the same with a petition from the Prostitution Information Center, opposing basic measures because, it claimed, “Government databases are never temporary and never secret. Anyone registered as prostitute in the database will carry that label for the rest of their life. Although the Netherlands is a so-called ‘tolerant’ society, the limits to Dutch ‘tolerance’ and social acceptance are narrower than one might think,” it added. These measures deemed absolutely critical, by the country’s national rapporteur on trafficking, to producing some semblance of meaningful regulation had to be abandoned and even stripped from law before it could be passed. The Dutch may have intended to regulate prostitution, but success does not rest on intent.

Establishing even the most basic of facts about the trade there today remains difficult. Nobody can say, for example, precisely how many prostitutes operate in the Netherlands, even after all these years. The shroud which once enveloped the trade remains in place, but where it was once used as a reason to legalise it, it is now used to defend the trade against criticism now that it has been legalised. All that can be relied upon comes in the form of estimates. Terrifyingly, one of these, given in this year’s edition of the Global Slavery Index, puts the population of modern-day slaves in the Netherlands at a staggering 17,500 persons. Yes, that’s 17,500 slaves! Given that sex trafficking in prostitution is the main form of human trafficking experienced in the Western World, the sex trade in the Netherlands must predictably account for most of those held in slavery there. Is this the solution we seek to emulate?

With over 45 million believed to be living in its grasp, slavery has returned to the world. Ireland can certainly choose to legalise prostitution. It will not succeed at regulating it however, for the very same reasons the Dutch have failed. One can promote the cause of prostitutes or the cause of prostitution, but one cannot promote the cause of both. It has always been so, for it was written of King Cotton at the South, that he was not slowed by “the cries of the oppressed, while the citizens of the world are dragging forward his chariot, and shouting aloud his praise!” This is the choice before Ireland today: do we consent to protect the consumer or the consumed.

Read 1966 times Last modified on Wednesday, 01 February 2017 17:21

Got something to say? Go for it!

Make sure you enter all the required information, indicated by an asterisk (*). HTML code is not allowed.


 
 

Open Secrets: An Irish Perspective on Trafficking and Witchcraft

Open Secrets: An Irish Perspective on Trafficking and Witchcraft explores modern slavery, human trafficking, and their slaves, all from the perspective of present-day events in Ireland.

Happening Now

Saudi Arabia: Man questioned for filming, publishing clip of woman selling vegetables

This includes the production of offending material, whether pornographic or drug-related, and human trafficking. Penalties apply not only to the creation ...

Bringing National Security into our Daily Dialogue

He also served as the Associate Director of National Intelligence and ... International criminal groups are involved in drug trafficking, with illicit drugs ...

Upside Down Under

Whether it was drug or human trafficking, they were showing up in Mercer County, and it kept law enforcement busy and continually expanding.

Egypt to link Takaful cash support with preventing child marriage

El-Kabbaj added that marrying girls in inappropriate and unsafe marriages, which is considered human trafficking, is a crime punishable under ...

Black man enslaved by White restaurant manager should be awarded more than $500000, court ...

A Black man with intellectual disabilities who was enslaved for five years at a ... As part of his 2019 guilty plea to a forced...

Human trafficking tragedy: Boat sinks, killing 3 and injuring 27

... were hospitalized after a wooden boat capsized Sunday during a possible human smuggling operation just off the San Diego coast, authorities said.

WATCH NOW: Opening day at Twin Lakes Farmers' Market draws 1000 visitors to stands, petting...

... selling to raise funds for a month-long mission to Guatemala she will be going on later this summer to help refugees and victims of...

Nonprofit helps trafficking survivors rebuild life through crafting, empowerment

FORT WORTH, Texas — A recent study by the University of Texas at Austin estimates there are over 300,000 victims of human trafficking in the...

Financial sector fails human rights test

It is the principal reason why our traffic light system scores no green results in any of the five areas,” said Dr Sheehan, a leading...

The two teenagers tackling social issues with a print magazine

Rachel Zhou and Angelina Del Favero were just 14 when they started ... The second edition of imPower was about human trafficking and modern ...

An inside look at the smuggling operation of 90 migrants in Houston

Just after 9 a.m., a Houston Police Department SWAT team swarmed the property in response to a kidnapping call, only to uncover a possible smuggling ...

Growth in Burkina Faso gold mining fuels human trafficking

SECACO, Burkina Faso — For months, human traffickers beat and drugged ... is not being mined or processed by forced labor or exploited workers.

Cindy McCain calls continued probes into election outcome 'ludicrous' after Trump ranted at Mar-a ...

She also noted her history of working to combat human trafficking and human rights violations. Trump took to a Mar-a-Lago bandstand on Thursday ...

Police campaign looks to help people in Bromsgrove spot the signs of modern slavery

The aim of the operation is to detect people being smuggled into the country, protect vulnerable workers, engage with businesses and gather ...

Drake Wuertz Fires Back At Criticism Over His 'Radical Views'

Drake Wuertz has seen the criticism of his conspiracy theory beliefs about masks and sex trafficking, and he isn't happy about it. As you may...

New report from Limerick researchers finds victims of human trafficking are 'hidden in plain sight'

Data collated for the Human Trafficking and Exploitation Project on the Island of Ireland (HTEPII), led by MIC, has shown that the number of adults...

European migration policies should prioritize health needs and life saving strategies

[6] Furthermore, organisations conducting lifesaving search and rescue operations often face accusations of colluding with human traffickers. [7].

Time allocated for Port City bill debate is insufficient -Opposition-

“This is a bill that is worthy of studying before the debate. But why is the debate taken up ... Human Trafficking by unlicensed agencies...

Three indicted on sex charges in suspected child trafficking case

“There's a lot of things that are being done in Pike County.” Robert Earl Varnado was arrested as the result a traffic stop in May...

Behind bars Nine jailed for brutal killing of alleged Romanian pimp Virgil Busa in Meath

Romanian authorities allege Busa was killed on the orders of rival pimp ... criminal group in Ireland specialising in human trafficking and prostitution.

Winners and losers emerging from the 2021 Legislative Session

Bill tackling the Florida Building Code: Passed. Bills addressing restitution, human trafficking, wildlife racketeering, code enforcement and ratifying ...

Cindy McCain Says She'd Be 'Honored' to Serve Ambassadorship for Biden

In an interview on CNN's “State of the Union,” McCain said she's proud of the work she's done so far for the administration in “human...

Eight cited in Portland Police human trafficking sting operation

According to authorities, the men contacted undercover officers who posted decoy ads on known human trafficking websites and tried to arrange ...

Human trafficking warning: It's happening today, right now, in every city and every town

Bronagh Andrew, operations manager for Trafficking Awareness Raising Alliance (TARA), is calling for the criminalisation of paying for sex in off-street ...

SUNDAY CONVERSATION: US Rep. McCaul witnesses 'dire' crisis at Mexican border

That perhaps smugglers brought her to the border. And these smugglers are taking advantage of families - charging them thousands of dollars and ...

Opinion: Cindy McCain and the torment of perfection

She would also find her own identity pursuing humanitarian causes, including the fight against human trafficking,. Cindy McCain's decision to endorse ...

Uighur forced labour: Xinjiang exports to US on rise despite sanctions

... living and working conditions that may constitute arbitrary detention, human trafficking, forced labour and enslavement by the use of forced labour.

Marilyn Manson fires back after being sued for 'sexual assault & sex trafficking' by Game...

According to the lawsuit, the hitmaker is also being accused of committing human trafficking when he “employed fraud” in bringing Bianco to the ...

Cabo Delgado insurgency: The shifting shape of the illicit economy in northern Mozambique

The ongoing fighting has had a knock-on effect on the illicit trafficking routes that have long been deeply entrenched in Cabo Delgado, but not in...

The border crisis is not the crisis you think | Opinion

These children are fleeing violence. Honduras and El Salvador have the two highest homicide rates in the world. Drug trafficking has created gangs and ...

You can help CARE House, which sees increasing risk of child abuse during pandemic

... House, the local organization that responds to allegations of child sexual abuse, severe physical abuse and minor victims of human trafficking.

Expert: 'I can assure you it happens in every small town in Mississippi'

Human trafficking doesn't always involve a creep in a panel van lying in wait to scurry away with unsuspecting kids. In fact, some of it...

More Than 800 Migrants Rescued at Sea Head to Italy | Voice of America -...

SOS Mediterranee said some passengers told rescuers they had been beaten by smugglers based in Libya and forced to embark on the unseaworthy ...

Timken: Biden Border Crisis directly affects Ohio

Third, open borders mean increased human trafficking and drug smuggling, both of which greatly impact Ohio. The seizure of fentanyl at the border ...

Human Trafficking Sting Leads To 8 Facing Criminal Charges

Portland Police say the Human Trafficking Unit cited 8 men in an undercover operation which was conducted in April. Police say officers posted online ...

Commentary: Human trafficking is everywhere you look — including Idaho

Economic instability breeds just the kind of vulnerability on which sexual traffickers prey. Two-thirds of human trafficking victims are people of color. As ...

WWE NXT Referee Rants About Criticism Of His “Radical Views”

In the video, Wuertz can be seen arguing that a mask mandate “puts vulnerable children at risk for being preyed upon by traffickers,” since “non-verbal ...

PH strengthens commitment to combat child trafficking

... and respond to child labor trafficking, provide comprehensive services to protect child trafficking victims, and prevent future human trafficking crimes.

The controversial Seaspiracy documentary may make you rethink your dinner choices

The controversial Seaspiracy documentary may make you rethink your ... groups that are behind drug trafficking, human trafficking and other crimes.

Overseas workers accusing China of forced labour, human rights violations

Washington Post also quoted the report, which described that overseas Chinese workers are victims of human trafficking and forced labour and these ...

About David Lohan

David Lohan is an author and researcher on modern slavery, a phenomenon otherwise known as human trafficking. He first encountered the issue of modern slavery during his work with an organization providing outreach to refugees and asylum seekers. His first book on the subject, a co-authored work, explored the role played by African witchcraft in present-day slavery. He holds a bachelor's degree in engineering and several post-graduate qualifications. His Master of Art (Politics) research explored policy approaches aimed at combating slavery. He is presently working on his second book on modern slavery.

With a commitment to victims of modern slavery.

© Copyright 2016 by DavidLohan.com. All Rights Reserved.

Back to the top.